|T O P I C R E V I E W|
|LM-12||Was there an Apollo 16 backup crew patch, or is the backup crew wearing the prime crew patch in this photo?|
|KAPTEC||Good question. Is there someone who knows the answer? |
|randy||It sure looks like the prime crew patch, from what I can see.|
|LM-12||Perhaps the backup crew patch had the original design, or a very similar one, with the names changed. |
|Besixdouze||Check out this link.|
This gives a good account of the suit worn by Fred Haise which is, most likely, the one he is wearing in this shot.
|LM-12||Hard to believe that is the same suit, with the Duke name tag and no red stripes. What is the suit number?|
|Besixdouze||On further investigation, the Apollo Lunar Surface Journal gives astronaut Haise two unique suit numbers - 324 for Primary and 305 for Training, neither of which had been used before. Likewise Mitchell with 325 and 321. Roosa has 401 and 085 which he recycled as back-up on Apollo 17 so the mystery deepens. |
Maybe the crew needed to wear the prime crews suits for this photo opportunity which certainly looks staged. It's a shot I haven't seen before and a higher resolution version would obviously help. Anyone have one?
|LM-12||Those look like beta cloth mission patches to me.|
The crew might very well be wearing the prime suits as you suggest. I don't recall ever seeing Apollo mission patches on the training suits of a backup crew.
Had Apollo 19 not been cancelled, I guess it would have been Haise, Pogue and Carr in the photo.
|spaced out||I don't seen any reason to suspect that embroidered patches were produced for any backup crews apart from Apollo 14. Or am I missing something?|
|LM-12||Here is an Apollo 16 training photo of Haise and Mitchell. The name tags on the RCUs are Young and (looks like) Duke.|
|Robert Pearlman|| |
quote: Here are the two photos from the sequence as included on Retro Space Images' Apollo 16 disc (click to view in full resolution):
Originally posted by Besixdouze:
It's a shot I haven't seen before and a higher resolution version would obviously help. Anyone have one?
|LM-12||Is there a date for the black and white photos?|
|Gonzo||And if you follow the link Mike (besixdouze) gave above, they are clearly beta cloth. |
And no, I've never heard of any embroidered backup crew patches other than Apollo 14 either.
|LM-12||A similar photo of the Apollo 15 crew shows that Al Worden was missing his beta cloth mission patch.|
|Philip||Interesting topic with rarely seen photos!|
|LM-12||Looks like the beta cloth mission patches weren't available yet when this Apollo 16 prime crew portrait was taken.|
|LM-12||The black and white Apollo 16 backup crew photos posted above might have been taken on April 11, 1972. Haise, Roosa and Mitchell were suited up at KSC for CMS/EVA training on that day.|
Photo 72-H-427 was taken at KSC and is dated April 12, 1972. The prime and backup crews were both suited up for launch/TLI sim training on that day.
Young does not have a beta cloth mission patch on his spacesuit, but he does appear to have the design of a four-leaf clover on his suit at waist level.
|LM-12||Looks like the Apollo 17 crew had beta cloth mission patches on their training suits also. I would say those were training suits because of the "E. CERNAN" name tag and the dirt on his sleeve.|
Originally posted by Besixdouze:
Roosa has 401 and 085 which he recycled as back-up on Apollo 17 so the mystery deepens.
In the photo, the NASA logo location on Roosa seems to indicate an A7L suit. The connectors seem to indicate an A7LB suit. Perhaps he is wearing a modified version of his Apollo 14 flight suit (085).
|J.L||I pulled those images out of the KSC archives over 10 years ago. Been trying to get back in ever since. These shots are a good example of what is still locked away.|
|LM-12||Must be some real gems buried in those archives.|
|LM-12||The National Air and Space Museum has this photo of Roosa's "flown" Apollo 14 A7L suit.|
|mach3valkyrie||What happened to the Apollo 14 beta cloth patch and NASA beta cloth patch?|
|Robert Pearlman||All of the Apollo astronauts were presented the patches from their suits as a memento. |
Only Armstrong, Aldrin and Collins declined the offer, wanting to keep the suits from the first moon landing mission intact.
|LM-12||The NASM photo description does not mention that the suit was modified after the Apollo 14 mission.|
Roosa's flown Apollo 14 suit is 085. 085 was reused as his Apollo 16 and 17 backup crew training suit. The NASA patch location hints that he is wearing the 085 training suit (and not the 401 primary suit) in the black and white photos. And it seems more likely to me that they would put the Apollo 16 patches on the training suits rather than the primary suits. So I would say that the flown suit in the NASM photo is the same suit that Roosa is wearing in the black and white photos.